DodsleyCritic's avatar

DodsleyCritic

65 Watchers486 Deviations
31.3K
Pageviews

Gallery

Literature

Dodsley's Thoughts - Equestria Girls

The Equestria Girls movies are a weird thing. Essentially, Hasbro wanted that Monster High fanbase and fused MLP with it in order to make some cash. What came out was 4 movies, some shorts, some movie/long episodes and a few specials. The movies, in hindsight, seem like a testing ground for some of the stories and characters we'd see later in the main show and I'll get to that in Rainbow Falls. I've wanted to discuss them for a while as they seem to be rather divisive. You either love them, hate them or don't give a crap about them. Let's see how the first movie pans out. The first movie starts after the events of Season 3. An odd placement considering the whole Twilight thing and this movie not addressing it at all. It doesn't really matter just a thing to note. Twilight and her friends are staying in the castle. They do show that Twilight is struggling to adjust to her newfound status as well as her wings, which is good enough for this movie. We get some good comedy and moments

All

486 deviations
Literature

Dodsley's Thoughts - Equestria Girls

The Equestria Girls movies are a weird thing. Essentially, Hasbro wanted that Monster High fanbase and fused MLP with it in order to make some cash. What came out was 4 movies, some shorts, some movie/long episodes and a few specials. The movies, in hindsight, seem like a testing ground for some of the stories and characters we'd see later in the main show and I'll get to that in Rainbow Falls. I've wanted to discuss them for a while as they seem to be rather divisive. You either love them, hate them or don't give a crap about them. Let's see how the first movie pans out. The first movie starts after the events of Season 3. An odd placement considering the whole Twilight thing and this movie not addressing it at all. It doesn't really matter just a thing to note. Twilight and her friends are staying in the castle. They do show that Twilight is struggling to adjust to her newfound status as well as her wings, which is good enough for this movie. We get some good comedy and moments

Featured

486 deviations
Literature

Journal of Good Animation - Secret of My Excess

It's a spike episode and not only that but a lore episode. This is the first time Dragon culture is really discussed apart from the gem thing. Let's see how it goes. The episode with Twilight sorting shenanigans and Spike fauning over a fire ruby. Rarity comes over and Spike gives her the jewel after some prodding. They do make it pretty clear that Rarity's main reason for wanting the jewel is Spike is going to eat it. It's still a little odd that Rarity basically seduces the gem of him, whether the scenes were in Spike's head or not. Still, Rarity is overjoyed and it gets across that Spike is pretty generous. A bit of Spike comedy and then it's his birthday. The mane 6 come over and shower him in gifts. Just going to say this now, this episode has really good comedy, nothing out of this world but it gets a solid chuckle most of the time and keeps a really fun tone. Rarity mentions that she is making capes for the mane 6 after being inspired by the genorisity of Spike. I've just

Journal Of Good Animation

195 deviations
Literature

Diary of Bad Animation - The Mysterious MareDoWell

It's been well over a year. Mostly due to being busy and losing the drive for this but I thought I'd give it another go and what better episode to start on. The black sheep of the show, the Mysterious Mare-Do-Well. The episode starts with a Rainbow Dash fan club meeting. It's odd, doesn't really match the tone of the show and brings up a lot of questions that the show doesn't want to answer. This probably should have been later in the episode, it kind of makes the rest of the episode make even less sense. Especially because it's not just fillies and colts in the club. Anyway, the episode properly starts with Rainbow Dash saving a filly trapped in a well, Rainbow is surprised by the size of the crowd and is pretty humble. I guess the opening is to cement that there is a fan club for Rainbow but Scootaloo is the only one who is in most scenes and we already knew she admired Rainbow. Rainbow then stops a stroller falling down a hill, makes a bad joke and then makes sure to grab the

Diary Of Bad Animation

122 deviations
Literature

Dodsley's Thoughts - Friendship is Magic

I have been looking for something to review for a while. I worked best with a goal or target in mind but I couldn't really find anything to review that met that. That isn't to say I haven't had things I have wanted to review but I just procrastinate over them to the point where I don't want to do anymore. So, I have decided to do a full MLP review. Each episode reviewed over the seven seasons. Of course I have done 5 and 6 and some other random episodes. But I thought it was time to do every episode. I am currently marathoning the show (I have just finished season 4) so I thought it was a good time to start. It is going to work like my S6 rev

MLP Season 1

26 deviations
Journal Of Good Animation - Tanks For The Memories

MLP Season 5

12 deviations
Literature

Dodsley's Thoughts - The Crystalling

I have decided to go through Season 6 of MLP and give it a watch, since I have missed nearly every episode. So, I thought I might as well review the season, starting with the opening two-parter. To give a brief overview, I found the episode fine, not great but nothing awful. When I first watched it, I found it much worse than on second viewing. The episode hits enough notes to not be bad, there is some nice comedy and interaction between characters. The ending is quite intense and the animation is quite pretty. Spike and Pinkie have decent appearances, and Glimmer works well of the other characters. The main issue I have is that there is so m

MLP Season 6

25 deviations
Literature

Dodsley's Thoughts - Equestria Girls

The Equestria Girls movies are a weird thing. Essentially, Hasbro wanted that Monster High fanbase and fused MLP with it in order to make some cash. What came out was 4 movies, some shorts, some movie/long episodes and a few specials. The movies, in hindsight, seem like a testing ground for some of the stories and characters we'd see later in the main show and I'll get to that in Rainbow Falls. I've wanted to discuss them for a while as they seem to be rather divisive. You either love them, hate them or don't give a crap about them. Let's see how the first movie pans out. The first movie starts after the events of Season 3. An odd placement considering the whole Twilight thing and this movie not addressing it at all. It doesn't really matter just a thing to note. Twilight and her friends are staying in the castle. They do show that Twilight is struggling to adjust to her newfound status as well as her wings, which is good enough for this movie. We get some good comedy and moments

Dodsley's Thoughts

57 deviations
Literature

Dodsley's Comparisons - TTG! Vs. Breadwinners

Okay, so I thought I would compare the two most hated current airing kids cartoons on the major networks which are CN, Nick, Disney, and the Hub which are Teen Titans Go! and Breadwinners.  These two are my least favorite shows on these networks so I thought I might as well find out which one is worse. So, I am going to compare them over about 5 topics, which are Quality, Stories and Characters, Comedy, and  Morals. I am going to choose a winner after each topic and then, the one with the most wins will be the winner. Right, so the main issue with these shows is a lack of quality. This shows are obviously cheap to make and it feels like ther

Dodsley's Comparisons

5 deviations
Dodsley's Character List - American Dad

Dodsley's Character List

6 deviations
Report Of Gaming - Batman - Arkham Knight

Report Of Gaming

6 deviations
Literature

Dodsley's Randoms - Regular Show Plot

Right, so I came up with a good way of fixing an episode that I found bad and I thought I would share it with you guys. I did this when thinking of ways to fix reviews of episodes I find bad and I came up with a fix for two episodes of Regular Show. This could be used for Best Burger In The World and Replaced. This is mainly for Replaced but it could be for Best Burger as well and I will explain at the end how. Right, so we start with Skips coming to Benson saying he is taking the next few days to spend time with Quips and his family. It could be a nice introduction to Quips. He has finished all of his jobs apart from one but he has Mordo and

Randoms

5 deviations
Journal Of Good Animation - Real Date

Valentine's Day Special

20 deviations
Journal of Good Animation - Band Geeks

Top 10 Favorite Cartoons

10 deviations
Literature

Diary Of Bad Animation - Quagmire's Mom (RE-DO)

This episode is awful. It has horrible cutaways that last too long and aren't funny. It has a plot that is massively contrived, on a side-note, I am stopping the Justin thing. It has disturbing themes and scenes. This episode also basically states that if you had a bad childhood, you don't need to take blame for your actions. Quagmire is a whining bastard who blames his mom for everything. If this episode actually made Quagmire responsible for his actions, then it wouldn't be so frustrating. This also leads to many questions that are never really answered. Why did Quagmire become a deviant if he was so angry at his mom? Why didn't Quagmire me

Bottom 10 Worst Cartoons

9 deviations
Journal Of Good Live-Action - No Refills

Journal Of Good Live-Action

6 deviations
Diary Of Bad Live-Action - iLove You

Diary Of Bad Live-Action

5 deviations